Review: Gilded Cage by Vic James

January 30, 2017
Review: Gilded Cage by Vic JamesGilded Cage by Vic James
Published by Del Rey Books on February 14th 2017
Pages: 368

Thanks to Del Rey Books for providing me with a copy of this book in exchange for my honest review. This does not affect my opinion of the book or the content of my review.

 LibraryThing button-amazon book-depository-button audible-button


Not all are free. Not all are equal. Not all will be saved.
Our world belongs to the Equals — aristocrats with magical gifts — and all commoners must serve them for ten years. But behind the gates of England's grandest estate lies a power that could break the world.
A girl thirsts for love and knowledge.
Abi is a servant to England's most powerful family, but her spirit is free. So when she falls for one of the noble-born sons, Abi faces a terrible choice. Uncovering the family's secrets might win her liberty, but will her heart pay the price?
A boy dreams of revolution.
Abi's brother, Luke, is enslaved in a brutal factory town. Far from his family and cruelly oppressed, he makes friends whose ideals could cost him everything. Now Luke has discovered there may be a power even greater than magic: revolution.
And an aristocrat will remake the world with his dark gifts.
He is a shadow in the glittering world of the Equals, with mysterious powers no one else understands. But will he liberate—or destroy?

In an atmosphere somewhat reminiscent of  Hunger Games and Red Rising (and many other dystopian novels), the world we encounter has a stark division between the classes. There are the elite Skilled, who though fewer in numbers, control Britain. The Skilled, as you may guess, have magical skills that allow them to do extraordinary things, such as heal themselves, repair broken objects and enforce the Silence (which ultimately means, messing with peoples brains to prevent them from speaking about things that the Skilled person does not want to be discussed).

The general masses of normal people usually have little or no contact with Skilled, who are perceived as untouchable, unknowable things. People are not real sure how much of their fabled powers are truth versus exaggeration. I found in this book neither side sees a humanity in the other group.  Through one POV we get an inside look at Millmoor, a slavetown. We also get to see that some slaves are able to find ways to rebel, and I found this to be exciting and fun. These sections were hands down my favorite within the book. We also get perspectives from a family living within a Skilled household, serving their slavedays as personal servants. This gives a closer look at the Skilled people, we get to see a more human side to them than just the gossip and legends that float around.

In general, regular people are free to live their lives, blissfully ignorant of what the Skilled do. That is they are all free to live their lives outside of a mandatory 10 year term for what they call “slavedays”. Every citizen must serve 10 years, during which time they are no longer considered to be citizens. They are dehumanized, stripped of any and all civil rights and treated as slaves (as the name implies). It is an interesting premise, it also emphasizes the us versus them mentality.

Unfortunately, I did have a few issues with this book. First, there is the romance. Now, I’m using that word loosely because to me, this was not romance, but rather instant infatuation (or I guess insta-love). It is the type of thing that just strikes me as baffling and irritating rather than romantic. I found it to be completely unnecessary to the plot or my enjoyment and engagement with the books. And because of the mindless aspect it gives the characters involved, it was actually a deterrent, making the characters feel shallow and superficial. Some people like this type of insta-love relationship, but personally I just don’t get it. I need there to be some personalized relationship building in order to really feel the connection and motivation that two characters develop between themselves.

The other issue I had with the book is that it was terribly predictable. There were certain things that felt like they were supposed to be “twists” or “reveals”, but you could see them coming from so far away, it was very anti-climatic. I found this issue to be much more minor than the insta-love because while it may impact the level of suspense and surprise you get from your reading experience, I can’t say it bothered me either. I was still able to enjoy the ride as the story went along the expected path.

Ultimately, I am left feeling like I was probably not the best target audience for this book. I enjoy the concept of slave days, and really enjoyed the sections inside of Millmoor, but over all I didn’t connect quite as well with this as I had hoped to. I think the book is probably quite good for certain audiences, readers who are not as quick to judge a romance as I am.

Review originally posted on The Speculative Herald.



  • imyril January 30, 2017 at 6:28 am

    I wasn’t fan of the insta-love, but I gave it a pass as I recall being roughly that easily led by my hormones as a teenager – and at least the characters got to know and respect one another on the back of their crush (as opposed to wilfully ignoring what terrible people they were – imagine if Abby had crushed on either of the other brothers, who were both objectively awful people). Still, it helped make Abby less interesting than Luke, which is unfortunate – she was shown to be clever, capable and compassionate, but it was sometimes overshadowed by her mooning over her master.

    I think your criticism of its predictability is spot on – as you say, it didn’t particularly bother me, but it sounds like I enjoyed the ride more than you did!
    imyril recently posted…Redux: January gets off to a good startMy Profile

  • Nathan (@reviewbarn) January 30, 2017 at 8:16 am

    I admit I wasn’t impressed with the premise of this one which seemed even by dystopia standards far fetched. Insta love would probably put me over the edge.
    Nathan (@reviewbarn) recently posted…Fantasy Review: ‘Walk on Earth a Stranger’ by Rae CarsonMy Profile

  • Maddalena@spaceandsorcery January 30, 2017 at 3:05 pm

    Since I first read the premise of this one, and after seeing a couple of reviews, I’ve been intrigued by the concept and will certainly give this book a try but… your mention of “insta-love” (one of my most dreaded tropes) did cool my enthusiasm a little. I just read another story where this kind of trope somewhat ruined the overall plot, and I’m not ready to face another, not so soon anyway…

    Thanks for sharing! 🙂
    Maddalena@spaceandsorcery recently posted…Review: REVENGER, by Alastair ReynoldsMy Profile

    • Lisa (@TenaciousReader) January 30, 2017 at 7:51 pm

      Yeah, it really irked me, but I’ve seen some positive reviews for it where people weren’t as bothered as I was (my tolerance for this is super low)
      Lisa (@TenaciousReader) recently posted…Review: Gilded Cage by Vic JamesMy Profile

  • Rebecca Forrester January 30, 2017 at 7:38 pm

    The insta-infatuation as you put it is pretty annoying. I mostly just roll my eyes and carry on unless it’s a MAJOR plot point.

  • Mogsy @ BiblioSanctum January 30, 2017 at 9:14 pm

    I finished this one and didn’t love it, didn’t hate it. I was just completely ambivalent towards it, which in some ways is worse than if I’d hated it, I think. It just left me cold.
    Mogsy @ BiblioSanctum recently posted…Excerpt and Giveaway: The Stars Are Legion by Kameron HurleyMy Profile

  • Lynn January 31, 2017 at 2:28 pm

    There were parts of this that were promising but to be honest I really couldn’t buy into the world and the slave days and it just bothers me too much.
    Lynn 😀

  • Danya @ Fine Print February 3, 2017 at 2:37 pm

    I was so excited about this one when the buzz first started, but the more I hear about the slave days (and the lack of explicable reason for it within the world) and insta-love the less interested I become. It just sounds very run-of-the-mill, and like there’s nothing too special about it.
    Danya @ Fine Print recently posted…Review: Glamour in Glass by Mary Robinette KowalMy Profile