Review: The Skull Throne by Peter V. Brett

March 21, 2015
Review: The Skull Throne by Peter V. BrettThe Skull Throne by Peter V. Brett
Series: The Demon Cycle #4
Also by this author: The Daylight War
Published by Del Rey on March 31, 2015
Genres: Epic, Fantasy
Pages: 704
Format: eARC

Thanks to Del Rey for providing me with a copy of this book in exchange for my honest review. This does not affect my opinion of the book or the content of my review.


 LibraryThing button-amazon book-depository-button audible-button

three-half-stars

The first three novels in New York Times bestselling author Peter V. Brett’s groundbreaking Demon Cycle series—The Warded Man, The Desert Spear, and The Daylight War—set a new standard for heroic fantasy. The powerful saga of humans winnowed to the brink of extinction by night-stalking demons, and the survivors who fight back, has kept readers breathless as they eagerly turned the pages. Now the thrilling fourth volume, The Skull Throne, raises the stakes as it carries the action in shocking new directions.   The Skull Throne of Krasia stands empty.   Built from the skulls of fallen generals and demon princes, it is a seat of honor and ancient, powerful magic, keeping the demon corelings at bay. From atop the throne, Ahmann Jardir was meant to conquer the known world, forging its isolated peoples into a unified army to rise up and end the demon war once and for all.   But Arlen Bales, the Warded Man, stood against this course, challenging Jardir to a duel he could not in honor refuse. Rather than risk defeat, Arlen cast them both from a precipice, leaving the world without a savior, and opening a struggle for succession that threatens to tear the Free Cities of Thesa apart.   In the south, Inevera, Jardir’s first wife, must find a way to keep their sons from killing one another and plunging their people into civil war as they strive for glory enough to make a claim on the throne.   In the north, Leesha Paper and Rojer Inn struggle to forge an alliance between the duchies of Angiers and Miln against the Krasians before it is too late.   Caught in the crossfire is the duchy of Lakton—rich and unprotected, ripe for conquest.   All the while, the corelings have been growing stronger, and without Arlen and Jardir there may be none strong enough to stop them. Only Renna Bales may know more about the fate of the missing men, but she, too, has disappeared. . . .   Praise for Peter V. Brett’s novels of The Demon Cycle   The Warded Man   “There is much to admire in Peter Brett’s writing, and his concept is brilliant. There’s action and suspense all the way.”—Terry Brooks   “[A] fast-paced and thoroughly enjoyable dark fantasy.”—The Miami Herald   The Desert Spear   “Inspired, compelling, and totally addictive: the most significant and cinematic fantasy epic since The Lord of the Rings.”—Paul W. S. Anderson, director of Resident Evil: Afterlife   “Fans of epic fantasy in the tradition of Robert Jordan and George R. R. Martin will enjoy the arrival of a strong voice in multivolume epic fantasy.”—Library Journal   The Daylight War   “Highly entertaining, fast-paced, and action-packed.”—SF Site   “[Brett is] at the top of his game.”—Tor.comFrom the Hardcover edition.

I found the Skull Throne to be an improved reading experience from what I had with the Daylight War. To be honest, I was not sure if I wanted to continue the series, but my enjoyment of the first two books convinced me to give the series another shot. Thankfully my key complaints in the Daylight War were not carried through to The Skull Throne.

First, while Arlen does still have a bit of an accent, I don’t think it was anything like it was in Daylight War. I was grateful for this (even if it wasn’t a major complaint). Renna also did not seem to annoy me as much in this, perhaps its because we just didn’t get as much of her, especially not as much Renna and Arlen together. And sexual manipulation was not the only tool allotted to women in this book. I was quite thankful for this last one.

I’m still not a fan of Krasian culture. The treatment of women and those outside their religion, or even outside of their warrior class, is just abhorrent. I can find it depressing to read, to be honest. And I feel like everything is taken to such an extreme that the characters and culture itself just seem to be more caricatures than anything relatable. The Krasians are always good for action packed scenes, but my detachment from the characters definitely dulls the experience.

The structure of this book is different than the standard epic fantasy. The first third of the book focuses on Everam’s Bounty and the set of characters there, then the next section is set in the Hollow and then the setting switches one last time (when everything comes to a head). It seems that typically these POVs/settings would be interspersed. The format made it feel almost like several separate stories. While I was not thrilled to start with the Krasians given my experience with The Daylight War, I do think this format worked quite well for this book.

One important thing to note here is that in previous books Arlen and/or Jardir have been primary characters. That was not the case in The Skull Throne. They are important to the overall story line of the series, obviously, but they were featured rarely. In fact, I mentioned Renna not being in this much (as a positive) and I would guess she had twice as many pages as Arlen or Jardir. That’s a guess, maybe I’m wrong. But still, the point is we see very little of Arlen or Jardir. In fact, the bits they were featured didn’t add much to this story, but I suspect it is set up for the next book. The focus of The Skull Throne is really how everyone is coping without either Deliverer there to lead them. It provides the opportunity for some to be opportunistic (*cough*Jayan – Jardir’s annoyance of a son*cough*) and others to come together to provide a solution for survival rather than waiting for someone else to “deliver” them from the evil demons.

I found the section in the Hollows strangely addictive, but not in the standard epic fantasy way. Fellow reviewer Mogsy referred to it as Days of Our Lives in the Hollow because of the soap-opera style drama in her review at The Bibliosanctum. That is quite apt, actually, at times I felt it was actually pushing Jerry Springer levels of drama revolving around Leesha’s baby (and who the father may or may not be) as well as Rojer and his wives. Yeah, multiple wives, and those being from enemy land during a time of war, that can create some drama in a small town! So I found myself quite into this section, but was also terribly aware that the reasons I enjoyed it had nothing to do with my typical reading preferences. It had nothing to do with world building, unique story telling, politics, backstabbing, survival or anything else like that. It was all Jerry Springer style drama played out in the Hollow. I was waiting for the chairs to start flying.

I’m left feeling like the bulk of important things that happened in this book happened in the last couple hundred pages. There certainly were key things before then, but wow, there some major events right up to the very end. Lots of action, plotting, quests for power. Pretty much, it was war. And with that can come unpredictability and changes that will impact everything else yet to come. I definitely plan on finishing the series out, if nothing else, there’s probably still some baby drama to come! Just kidding, there are some interesting storylines coming together, and I am quite intrigued to see how they play out.

three-half-stars

12 Comments

  • Bob (@beauty_in_ruins) March 21, 2015 at 3:18 pm

    ” Days of Our Lives in the Hollow” – couldn’t have said it better myself! I found myself quickly growing tired of Leesha, but I quite enjoyed the way Rojer’s situation developed. You’re right about Brett constructing his novels oddly, in chunks rather than interspersing the POVs, but here I though it worked, especially once we get into the clash of cultures at the end of the book.
    Bob (@beauty_in_ruins) recently posted…From the Shelf to the Page: This Week in the RuinsMy Profile

    • Lisa (@TenaciousReader) March 23, 2015 at 7:16 pm

      Yes, while I found the set up different, and initially didn’t like it because it meant I was stuck in Krasia, I do think it worked quite well. And yes, Mogsy definitely nailed it with “Days of Our Lives in the Hollow”! 🙂
      Lisa (@TenaciousReader) recently posted…Review: The Skull Throne by Peter V. BrettMy Profile

  • Mogsy @ BiblioSanctum March 21, 2015 at 7:17 pm

    I’m glad I wasn’t the only one addicted to Days of Our Lives in the Hollow, I was starting to feel a little sheepish about that 😛

    I think I actually enjoyed The Daylight War slightly more than this one, but it’s almost a toss up. Basically I don’t think any of the sequels have quite lived up to the first book, which was my favorite. The Krasians really put a damper on things. You’re absolutely correct that they feel more like caricatures than real people, which makes their characters predictable and boring. And YES, Jayan was infuriating!
    Mogsy @ BiblioSanctum recently posted…Book Review: The Autumn Republic by Brian McClellanMy Profile

    • Lisa (@TenaciousReader) March 23, 2015 at 7:22 pm

      Ha ha ha! Nope, it reeled me in, and probably a good thing because I was on the fence there for a bit about finishing it. Glad I did though, and feel confident I’ll read the end of the series now. But your right, the first book was definitely the strongest, which is a shame.
      Lisa (@TenaciousReader) recently posted…Review: The Skull Throne by Peter V. BrettMy Profile

  • Tammy @ Books, Bones & Buffy March 21, 2015 at 8:12 pm

    Wow, you mean the series isn’t over yet? I don’t know about this one, I’m always leery when reviewers I trust think the series is starting to go downhill. There are just so many other books to read:-D
    Tammy @ Books, Bones & Buffy recently posted…Over-Booked [21] – A Book Haul PostMy Profile

    • Lisa (@TenaciousReader) March 23, 2015 at 7:24 pm

      Nope, not done yet. Think the next one is the final one. I honestly don’t know that I’d recommend the series at this point. Book 3 really annoyed me TBH (I posted a rant instead of a review). I am enjoying it again and want to see where it goes, but like you said, there are so many books out there!
      Lisa (@TenaciousReader) recently posted…Review: The Skull Throne by Peter V. BrettMy Profile

  • Dragana March 23, 2015 at 10:07 am

    This is one of those popular fantasy series that I didn’t read. Hopefully I will catch up soon.
    I’m glad to hear that you enjoyed this book more than previous one. 🙂
    Dragana recently posted…Book Review: Written in Red by Anne BishopMy Profile

  • Lynn March 23, 2015 at 5:12 pm

    I need to catch up with this – I read the first two but then just fell behind and I’m finding it really difficult to give myself the push to continue. Don’t know why – although they are huge and some of the reviews I’ve read I think have put me off a little! Need to just decide if I’m going to get back to it or not.
    Lynn 😀
    Lynn recently posted…Three Parts Dead by Max Gladstone, Final InstalmentMy Profile

    • Lisa (@TenaciousReader) March 23, 2015 at 7:26 pm

      I completely understand! They books are huge. Now that I’m invested, I wanted to finish, but I’m not sure I’d start it knowing what I know now. If I did, I might just try to stop after the first one. Honestly, I wish I hadn’t read Daylight War, but lots of other people liked it more than I did.
      Lisa (@TenaciousReader) recently posted…Review: The Skull Throne by Peter V. BrettMy Profile

  • Danya @ Fine Print March 25, 2015 at 8:27 pm

    Wow, 700 pages. I know that the books in ASOIAF are longer, but still. That’s a lot! I’ve been wanting to read this series quite badly for a while now, but now I HAVE to read it. I mean, Days of Our Live in the Hollow? I need to know what that’s about!!
    Danya @ Fine Print recently posted…Series Review: Alpha & Omega by Patricia BriggsMy Profile